SecureFiles in Oracle Database 11g
January 29, 2009
Large Objects (LOBs): A Brief History Lesson
The first time I encountered an application that required a binary large object (BLOB) was literally a millennium ago. In 1999, our IT organization at the American Medical Association (AMA) in Chicago, Illinois was tasked with upgrading that organizations seventy-plus mainframe applications into four client server applications. I led one of several development teams that used PowerBuilder to develop the next generation of client-server front-end applications.
Our flagship membership processing application had a requirement to store a physicians personal photograph so that when she accessed the AMAs web site, her picture would appear next to her personal information. We later expanded this requirement so that we could store images of a physician practice location or an organizations logo. We also developed a mailing list application that utilized Microsoft Word documents as templates for mailing labels, form letters, and fax cover sheets so that we could easily generate documents for distributing membership communication in standardized formats. During the initial project development cycle we utilized Informix as our RDBMS, and it had the capability to store JPEGs and Microsoft Word documents as BLOBs.
At that time our long-term vision for these images and documents was that theyd be loaded one time, updated only infrequently, and would be relatively small in size. And as it turns out, we werent the only IT team with this relatively narrow vision; in fact, these assumptions are reflected in the initial roll-out of Large Object capabilities in Oracle Database 8i as well:
So ... Whats Changed?
At the risk of overstating the obvious, the footprint of Large Objects has increased exponentially within our databases over the last decade. Its being driven by diverse business needs that span every industry: medical and pharmaceutical applications that capture and serve up patient images, manufacturing applications that store components designs, and semi-structured data that business-to-business (B2B) applications use to order products to replenish a companys warehouse. However, these newer application requirements have several things in common:
LOBs, the Next Generation: SecureFiles
As a result of these new business requirements, the LOB data type has been redesigned completely in Oracle 11g Release 1. This new LOB datatype is called a SecureFile, but unfortunately thats a bit of a misnomer because security enhancements are a relatively small subset of SecureFiles features, as well see throughout this article series.
Performance and Manageability Improvements. Since the sources of LOBs have increased in size by several orders of magnitude in the past decade, it was obvious that the methods that load, store, and return data from LOBs needed complete refurbishment. Oracle 11g doesnt disappoint in this regard:
Bigger CHUNK sizes. In prior releases, the maximum size of a chunk of LOB data that could be read or written at one time was limited to 32KB. Internal and external LOB sizes have grown exponentially since Oracle 8i, so this was a serious limitation to effective LOB I/O. Oracle 11g remedies this by automatically choosing an appropriate CHUNK size between the databases standard block size and a maximum of 64MB. Further, Oracle 11g helps limit the internal fragmentation of SecureFile LOBs by attempting to store extremely large SecureFile LOB segments on disk so that theyre physically adjacent. Finally, the ability to utilize variable CHUNK sizes means that the corresponding UNDO segments generated during updates of SecureFile LOBs only need to be as large as the CHUNKs and thus contain less wasted space.
Improved REDO and UNDO Generation. Before Oracle 11g, the Oracle DBA had relatively free rein when configuring CHUNK size, as well as the retention of undo segments for LOBs, and that didnt always yield optimal results. But since Oracle 11g will choose automatically the best method for generating redo and undo for SecureFile LOBs, only two storage-related parameters are required: RETENTION and MAXSIZE. The RETENTION directive tells Oracle 11g how to handle the consistent read data (stored in UNDO segments) for a SecureFile LOB. Heres how the setting affects read consistency:
The new MAXSIZE storage setting works in concert with the setting for RETENTION, and it determines the maximum size of a SecureFile LOB. When RETENTION is set to MAX, then the LOB is allowed to grow up to a size of MAXSIZE, after which space can be reclaimed from UNDO segments; otherwise, the MAXSIZE setting is treated as a hard limit on the size of the SecureFile LOBs segment.
Note that the storage attributes CHUNK, PCTVERSION, FREEPOOLS, FREELISTS, and FREELIST GROUPS are simply ignored for SecureFile LOBs
Intelligent Compression. This new feature allows Oracle 11g to compress and uncompress SecureFile LOB data automatically and transparently, and this means that disk space for these data is reduced dramatically. Whenever a query or DML statement retrieves or applies changes to a SecureFile LOBs data, Oracle 11g uncompresses only those data blocks needed for the operation, and it automatically maintains the required mapping between the uncompressed data blocks in the Database Buffer Cache and the database blocks on disk. There are two compression levels: MEDIUM (the default) and HIGH; specifying HIGH will tend to increase latency during SecureFile LOB access, but will also result in the highest storage compression ratios.
Automatic Deduplication. One of the more intriguing SecureFile LOB features is the ability for Oracle 11g to automatically locate any LOBs that store exactly the same data within the same table and column. Once detected, Oracle 11g will store only one copy of the LOB data. The advantage here, of course, is dramatically reduced amounts of disk space are needed to store the same amount of data; further, redo logging and UNDO is reduced significantly because an update to SecureFile LOB data doesnt require retaining duplicate versions of redo log entries and UNDO segments. Deduplication of SecureFile LOB data is enforceable at either the table or partition level. Note that deduplication does require the Oracle Advanced Compression option, a separately-licensed option thats also required for OLTP table compression and several other advanced compression features in Oracle 11g.
Transparent Encryption. Every organization has ethical and legal obligations to protect customer-sensitive information stored within LOBs. For example, a patients medical records and radiology images must be protected under HIPAA regulations. However, theres also enormous amounts of intellectual property information that must be stored in semi-structured object forms for example, molecular formulas and manufacturing blueprints that is crucial to any companys competitive advantage.
SecureFile LOBs fill this hitherto serious gap in database security because its now possible to encrypt LOB data within an Oracle 11g database. SecureFile LOBs are encrypted using the same Transparent Data Encryption (TDE) algorithms that were introduced in Oracle 10gR2, and this means its possible to encrypt either any or all SecureFile LOBs within the same table using the four standard TDE encryption algorithms (AES128, AES192, AES256 and 3DES168). Finally, note that TDE does require the Oracle Advanced Security pack, an extra-cost option, to enable encryption of SecureFile LOBs.
Wait! What About My Old LOBs?
The DBA must set the value of the COMPATIBLE initialization parameter to 220.127.116.11.0 or higher to enable SecureFile LOB features. However, the original LOB datatype and its capabilities are still preserved for backward compatibility: A pre-11gR1 LOB is now called a BasicFile. BasicFile and SecureFile LOBs can even co-exist in the same table. In fact, if a LOB is not specified as a SecureFile during its creation, then Oracle 11g simply assumes it to be a BasicFile LOB.
Controlling Selection of SecureFiles for LOB Storage. The new DB_SECUREFILE initialization parameter offers another layer of control over how Oracle 11g chooses the type of LOB to create when neither the BasicFile or SecureFile option is specified:
Note that if a SecureFile LOB storage option is specified during the creation or modification of a BasicFile LOB for example, TDE encryption, deduplication, or compression Oracle 11g will raise an exception during the operation.
Using SecureFiles: A Practical Example
To illustrate how simple and practical it is to create and use SecureFile LOBs, Ill construct a sample application that captures trouble ticket information. Along with each trouble ticket identifier and description, the application needs to retain a Microsoft Word document that each customer submits when a trouble ticket is created; optionally, the customer can also provide an appropriate screen print or other image in JPEG format to help clarify the problem encountered.
Ive provided the code to create the initial infrastructure for this application in Listing 1.1:
The sample Microsoft Word documents and JPEG files can be downloaded as a single ZIP file. To duplicate this application infrastructure, youll need to create directory folders that correspond to the ones created above and then copy the documents and images into their respective directories.
Now that my infrastructure is in place, Ill construct two tables to demonstrate how to store the trouble ticket information and related LOBs. As shown in Listing 1.2, both tables are virtually identical; however, table TRBTKT.TICKETS will utilize BasicFiles to store its LOBs, while, table TRBTKT.SECURE_TICKETS will use SecureFiles. Ill be using both tables in this article series to compare and contrast the different features of BasicFiles and SecureFiles.
Ill also construct a new package, TRBTKT.PKG_SECUREFILES, thats shown in Listing 1.3. Ill use this package to implement all methods for loading LOBs, determining LOB sizing and space utilization, and displaying rudimentary information from the character-based LOBs.
Next, Ill load sample data into table TRBTKT.TICKETS via calls to procedure AddTroubleTickets in package TRBTKT.PKG_SECUREFILES. Ive shown the invocation of this procedure in Listing 1.4. The sample Microsoft Word documents and JPEG files can be downloaded as a single ZIP file here; to duplicate my loading technique, youll need to create directory folders that correspond to the ones defined in for directory objects TRBTKT_DOCS and TRBTKT_IMGS.
Finally, Ill transfer the data from TRBTKT.TICKETS to TRBTKT.SECURE_TICKETS using a simple INSERT INTO ... SELECT statement as shown in Listing 1.5.
In the next article in this series, Ill delve a lot more deeply into the advanced capabilities of Oracle Database 11gs new SecureFile features, including:
References and Additional Reading
While Im hopeful that Ive given you a thorough grounding in the technical aspects of the features Ive discussed in this article, Im also sure that there may be better documentation available since its been published. I therefore strongly suggest that you take a close look at the corresponding Oracle documentation on these features to obtain crystal-clear understanding before attempting to implement them in a production environment. Please note that Ive drawn upon the following Oracle Database 11g documentation for the deeper technical details of this article:
B28279-02 Oracle Database 11g New Features Guide
B28320-01 Oracle Database 11g Reference Guide
B28393-03 Oracle Database 11g SecureFiles and Large Objects Developers Guide
B28419-02 Oracle Database 11g PL/SQL Packages and Types Reference
B28424-03 Oracle Database 11g Advanced Application Developers Guide